Coherence Research

Working papers · updated weekly

What sells on TikTok Shop

Research from our analysis of TikTok Shop: where revenue is growing and how it sells, each category in depth, which openings, formats and production choices sell, what is rising and fading, and what the season brings.

Creative19

One creative choice across TikTok Shop: openings, length and pacing, calls to action, audio, AI and more.

CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-70

AI UGC vs filmed UGC: how to evaluate the evidence

51,843 videos tracked, 9,371 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.6×
sales per view for fully AI-generated videos versus the market (90% range 1.4–1.9×; 103 videos, 1% of sales)
2.1×
sales per view for AI avatar presenters (range 1.6–2.8×), but only 16 videos and medium confidence
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-69

When to refresh UGC: planning around video shelf life

51,843 videos tracked, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
19.6%
of top-video revenue came from videos more than 3 months old
9.2%
of top-video revenue came from videos under a week old
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-68

UGC production style: polished or everyday footage

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
89.5%
of watched-video sales came from filmed live action videos
1.0×
sales per view for filmed live action (90% range 1.00–1.04), essentially the market average
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-67

UGC calls to action for TikTok Shop: a testing guide

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.07×
sales per view for orange cart prompts (90% range 1.05–1.10×), on 53.9% of watched-video sales
0.90×
sales per view for videos with no call to action (range 0.87–0.93×), on 36.5% of sales
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-66

The first frame of a UGC video: what to show

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.07
sales per view when face, text and product all appear in the first second (90% range 1.03–1.10; 1 = market average)
0.92
sales per view when only one of the three appears (90% range 0.88–0.96)
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-65

UGC voiceovers for TikTok Shop: what the data can tell us

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
40%
of sales among videos analysed in depth came from voice-over videos, the largest share of any audio style
1.05× vs 1.13×
sales per view for voice-over versus speaking on camera (90% ranges 1.02–1.07 and 1.10–1.16)
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-64

UGC with or without a creator on camera

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.045
sales per view, face in the first second (90% range 1.021–1.069; market average = 1)
0.899
sales per view when the creator is not on camera (0.868–0.932)
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-63

UGC testimonial videos: evidence and testing ideas

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.17×
sales per view for review or testimonial videos (90% range 1.12–1.22), from 1,071 videos
14.1%
share of watched-video sales carried by review or testimonial videos
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-62

UGC product demonstrations: what to test on TikTok Shop

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
36%
of watched-video sales came from demo or tutorial videos (3,163 videos), at 0.96× market sales per view (0.94–0.99)
1.24×
sales per view for voice-over B-roll (1.16–1.33, 561 videos), the highest of the formats with high confidence
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-61

UGC scripts for TikTok Shop: building an evidence-led brief

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.5×
sales per view for price or deal hooks vs the market average (90% range 1.37–1.58)
1.2×
sales per view for bold-claim hooks (1.19–1.29), which carried 17% of watched-video sales
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-60

UGC hook testing: a framework for TikTok Shop

51,843 videos tracked, 9,285 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
1.5×
sales per view for price or deal openings (90% range 1.37–1.58), the highest of the common hook types
1.2×
sales per view for bold-claim openings (1.19–1.29) across 1,361 videos, 17% of watched-video sales
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-59

UGC performance metrics: go beyond video views

51,843 videos tracked, 29 categories, 19 Sept–18 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 18 Oct
66.4%
of top-video revenue came with paid promotion, on 16.1% of views (a lower bound)
$17.06 vs $16.02
revenue per 1,000 views, organic vs paid-led top-selling videos
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-17

A face in the first second is associated with higher sales per view on TikTok Shop

13,304 videos tracked, 3,342 analysed in depth, 2 Sept–1 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
1.05×
sales per view for videos opening with a face (range 1.01–1.09), versus 0.94× without
1.08×
sales per view when face, text and product all appear in the first second (range 1.02–1.14)
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-19

Creators who show their face early sell at above-average rates on TikTok Shop

13,304 videos tracked, 3,342 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 2 Sept–1 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
1.06×
sales per view for videos with the creator's face in the first second (90% range 1.02–1.10)
0.89×
sales per view when the creator is not on camera (90% range 0.84–0.93)
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-15

Top-selling TikTok Shop videos that prompt comments or show the orange cart sell more per view than those with no call to action

13,304 videos tracked, 3,342 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 2 Sept–1 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
1.08×
sales per view for orange cart videos (90% range 1.04–1.12), against a market average of 1
58%
of watched-video sales came from videos using the orange cart
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-18

Ads and organic videos sell at similar rates among top TikTok Shop sellers, but the openings that work differ

13,304 videos tracked, 3,342 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 2 Sept–1 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
89.1%
of sales in the sample came from videos that ran as ads
0.995 vs 1.042
sales per view, ads vs organic (1 = market average); ranges overlap
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-16

Talking to camera sells more per view than trending sounds on TikTok Shop

13,304 videos tracked, 3,342 analysed in depth, 29 categories, 2 Sept–1 Oct 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
1.14×
sales per view for speaking on camera (90% range 1.08–1.19), the highest of the main audio types
0.76×
sales per view for trending sounds (0.70–0.81), despite 13.5% of watched-video sales
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-04

Price and bold-claim hooks sell more per view on TikTok Shop, while borrowed openers lag

Our analysis of 3,340 closely watched videos from a sample of 13,309 top-selling TikTok Shop videos across 29 categories, 2 September to 1 October 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
1.53×
Sales per view for price-or-deal hooks vs the market (90% range 1.37–1.71)
1.28×
Sales per view for bold-claim hooks, which carry 16% of watched-video sales
CreativeCIQ-WP-2026-03

Filmed video carries TikTok Shop sales while fully AI-made video stays rare and unproven

Our analysis of 13,309 top-selling TikTok Shop videos across 29 categories, 3,340 of them watched and coded, 2 September to 1 October 2026

Working paperv1 · 1 Oct
78%
Share of watched-video sales from video with no visible AI
20%
Share of sales from video with an AI voice-over, which sells at 0.95× per view